Is Aamir Khan’s ‘3 Idiots’ Copied From Thalapathy Vijay’s Tamil Film ‘Nanban’? This Viral X Post Falsely Claims So – Here’s the Truth!
One of the most beloved Bollywood films of the 21st century, Rajkumar Hirani’s 3 Idiots (2009) is a campus-based dramedy that continues to resonate with audiences. The film stars Aamir Khan in the lead, alongside Kareena Kapoor Khan, Sharman Joshi, R Madhavan, and Boman Irani in pivotal roles. Aamir Khan’s dual-named character, Ranchhoddas “Rancho” / Phunsukh Wangdu, has achieved cult status for his quirky attitude of motivating everyone around him. The film is widely celebrated for its inspiring themes and humorous sequences (though the ‘balatkaar‘ speech scene has aged poorly), and it remains a benchmark in Indian cinema. 3 Idiots Sequel in Works? Kareena Kapoor Khan Thinks So Thanks to an Aamir Khan, R Madhavan and Sharman Joshi Pic (Watch Video).
However, recently, a question has surfaced on the internet: is 3 Idiots copied from a Tamil film starring Thalapathy Vijay?
A viral post on X (formerly Twitter) has sparked this debate. The post features a montage of scenes from a Tamil movie called Nanban with the caption, “Bollywood ki ek hi masterpiece thi, woh bhi copy” (“Bollywood had only one masterpiece, and even that is a copy”). There are two things wrong with this claim.
Viral Post About ‘3 Idiots’ and ‘Nanban’
Sacchai chupayi gayi 🫠 pic.twitter.com/NJ1xxTXpLd
— 𝙎𝘼𝙍𝘾𝘼𝙎𝙌𝙊 (@sarcasqo) December 11, 2024
First off, Bollywood has produced a plethora of masterpieces over the decades, and it’s shortsighted to limit the industry’s achievements to just one film.
Secondly, 3 Idiots is not a copy of Nanban. A simple Google search or even a glance at their Wikipedia pages would clarify this unless the intent behind the claim is merely to farm engagement. Did ‘Garam Masala’ Copy ‘Boeing Boeing’? Video Clip Comparing Comic Scenes From Akshay Kumar-John Abraham’s Movie With 1965 American Comedy Is Going Viral – Here’s the Truth!
All You Need to Know About ‘3 Idiots’
3 Idiots is loosely inspired by banker-turned-author Chetan Bhagat’s bestselling debut novel Five Point Someone. Scripted by Hirani and Abhijat Joshi, the film follows Rancho, a brilliant yet unconventional student at a prestigious engineering college, as he challenges outdated teaching methods and inspires his friends to question societal norms. Beneath its humour and drama lies a mystery surrounding Rancho’s background, which culminates in a surprising twist in the climax.
Watch a Scene From ‘3 Idiots’:
When released, 3 Idiots became the highest-grossing Hindi film of all time, until it was dethroned by another Aamir Khan starrer, Dhoom 3.
All You Need to Know About ‘Nanban’
If 3 Idiots debuted in 2009, Nanban followed in 2012 as its official Tamil remake. Directed by Shankar – renowned for VFX-laden blockbusters like Indian, Mudhalvan/Nayak, Sivaji, Enthiran, 2.0, and Indian 2—Nanban marked a significant departure in his career. It was understated compared to his usual fare and his first official remake.
In Nanban, Thalapathy Vijay steps into Aamir Khan’s role, with Srikanth and Jiiva portraying characters originally played by R Madhavan and Sharman Joshi, respectively. Ileana D’Cruz plays the female lead. Thalapathy Vijay Birthday Special: From Master to Nanban, 7 Movie Looks of the Superstar That Won Us Over!
Watch a Scene From ‘Nanban’:
While Nanban performed modestly at the Tamil Nadu box office, it gained popularity overseas and has since developed a cult following. But let’s be clear: Nanban is a remake of 3 Idiots, not the other way around.
PS: Did you know that 3 Idiots also inspired a Mexican remake in 2017 titled 3 Idiotas? Just putting this out there before another netizen stumbles upon it and claims that 3 Idiots is a copy of a Mexican film!
(The above story first appeared on Today News 24 on Dec 12, 2024 04:26 AM IST. For more news and updates on politics, world, sports, entertainment and lifestyle, log on to our website todaynews24.top).
